Here’s a full review of The Disinvited (2024/25) — a taut psychological thriller that blends social commentary, suspense and indie grit into a surprisingly layered film.
🎬 Basic Info
- Title: The Disinvited (2024) Letterboxd+1
- Director / Writer: Devin Lawrence (co-written with Matthew Mourgides) Medium+1
- Cast: Sam Daly as Carl, Danielle Reynolds, Ryan Vincent, Alana Johnston, among others. Letterboxd+1
- Genre: Psychological thriller with darkly comedic and dramatic elements. morbidlybeautiful.com+1
- Runtime: ~91 minutes. Letterboxd+1
- Synopsis: Carl crashes an event at which he’s no longer welcome, triggering a day of betrayal, violence and heartbreak in a desert setting. When he realises he isn’t the only “un-invited guest”, he must choose between saving himself or risking everything for relationships he thought were behind him. Letterboxd+1
✅ What Works — Strengths
1. Atmosphere & Suspense
The film does a strong job of creating tension from the outset. The setting (an event in a remote desert locale), the theme of ostracism, and the gradual un-raveling of relationships give it a claustrophobic, haunting edge. As one critic observed:
“The Disinvited is a taut psychological thriller that punches above its weight.” morbidlybeautiful.com
The tone shifts from awkwardness to menace very effectively.
2. Social Commentary & Relevance
While it works as a thriller, the film also carries commentary about exclusion, friendship breakdown, and the desire to be “accepted”. Director Devin Lawrence explained that he was reflecting on how people are cut off when they don’t fit in anymore. Medium
This gives the story emotional texture beyond mere shocks.
3. Cast & Lead Performance
Sam Daly’s performance as Carl anchors the film. He plays their awkwardness, resentment and vulnerability with finesse. Several reviewers cite his performance as a standout. morbidlybeautiful.com+1
The supporting cast also contributes to the sense of fractured relationships and underlying tension.
4. Indie Craftsmanship & Technical Finesse
Given its modest budget, the film impresses in its production: cinematography, sound design and editing all come together to create a mood that feels more expansive than the resources might suggest. The review in Medium notes the way the film uses long takes and master shots to build tension. Medium
This technical competence elevates it above many low-budget thrillers.
⚠️ What Could Be Better — Weaknesses & Caveats
1. Predictability in Plot Beats
While the film handles its themes deftly, some narrative beats will feel familiar to seasoned thriller viewers: the un-welcome guest, the fractured friend group, the big confrontation. One review mentions that toward the end “it’s a bit predictable.” Letterboxd
If you’re seeking radical unpredictability, this might not satisfy entirely.
2. Empathy for the Protagonist
Because Carl’s character is flawed from early on (his motivations and social awkwardness are clearly problematic), some viewers may find it harder to fully root for him. One review notes:
“The main character was written in a very unlikable way … it made no real moves to showcase why we might care.” Letterboxd
The film asks the viewer to engage with an uneasy subject—how someone reacts when rejected—without always giving full justification for empathy.
3. Scope & Depth vs. Ambition
For a film that touches on big themes (belonging, exclusion, identity), there are moments when it feels slightly contained to its thriller elements and doesn’t fully explore every thread as deeply as possible. Some reviewers wish it delved more into the background of the characters or the broader social implications. Just For Movie Freaks
🧠 Themes & Key Insights
- Belonging vs Exclusion: At its core, the film is about being pushed out from a circle and what that does to someone.
- Identity & Social Friction: How we define ourselves in relation to others, and what happens when that relationship is severed.
- Friendship & Betrayal: The event that Carl crashes symbolises more than one invitation revoked; it stands for relational rupture.
- Isolation & Tension: The desert setting amplifies feelings of being out of place, exposed and vulnerable.
- Ambiguity & Consequence: The film leaves some moral questions open—what’s the cost of belonging? What’s the cost of being un-invited?
🎯 Final Verdict
The Disinvited is a compelling indie thriller—smart, stylish, and emotionally resonant. It will primarily appeal to viewers who appreciate tension, character-study and social undertones in the thriller format.
Rating: 7.5/10
- Why it earns this: Strong atmosphere, effective performances, deep thematic undercurrent, impressive craft for its scale.
- Why not higher: Some familiar plot structures, tricky empathy for the lead, slightly limited scope for its ambition.
Recommended for:
- Fans of psychological thrillers with character focus rather than purely action-driven plots.
- Viewers interested in independent films that explore social psychology and friendship dynamics.
- Those who enjoy movies that make you think about belonging and exclusion.
About the Author
