Here is a comprehensive, in-depth review of Sentimental Value — covering its story, strengths, weaker spots, thematic richness, and whether it’s worth your time.
🎬 Overview
Sentimental Value is a 2025 drama directed by Joachim Trier (co-written with Eskil Vogt) that explores family, memory, art and reconciliation. Wikipedia+2BFI+2
It stars Stellan Skarsgård as Gustav, a once-renowned filmmaker who returns to his daughters, Renate Reinsve (Nora) and Inga Ibsdotter Lilleaas (Agnes), after the death of their mother. Gustav attempts a kind of emotional comeback by making a film about their family home and past, stirring up long-buried grievances and unresolved traumas. Wikipedia+2That Shelf+2
The film premiered at the Cannes Film Festival in 2025 and won the Grand Prix. Wikipedia+1
✅ What Works
1. Emotionally rich dynamics
One of the strongest points is how the film depicts the brittle, complex relationships between father and daughters. Nora’s anger, Agnes’s quiet resignation, Gustav’s self-absorption—these are rendered with nuance and realism. For example, one reviewer described the film:
“Sentimental Value… uncommonly rich in emotional rewards and…” Hollywood Reporter+1
Another commentary notes:
“The characters are so fleshed-out…the backstories and present stories so engaging.” Metacritic
The performances—particularly Reinsve’s and Skarsgård’s—are widely praised. Reinsve again demonstrates her screen power. That Shelf
2. Formal ambition and fusion of cinema & family drama
Trier weaves together a film-within-a-film structure, archival footage resonances, and the physical space of the family home as metaphor. As one review states:
“Sentimental Value: an egotistical director tries to reconnect with his family through cinema in Trier’s gorgeous drama.” BFI+1
The film doesn’t just show familial conflict—it uses the tools of filmmaking (scripts, casting, retrospectives) to examine art’s capacity to heal or harm. Spike+1
3. Visual & thematic layers
The family home in Oslo, with its cracks and hidden histories, becomes its own character. One piece remarks:
“The house the girls grew up in… is a character unto itself.” Punch Drunk Critics
Themes of generational trauma, creativity vs. abandonment, memory vs. reality are layered rather than spelled out, making the film linger intellectually. a-rabbitsfoot.com+1
⚠️ What Doesn’t Work / Areas to Consider
1. Pacing and indulgence
Some critics argue the film is long, and its pace more meditative than gripping. The Guardian, for instance, writes:
“This long and slightly indulgent film… ranges across moods of rather serious wintriness and cinephile sadness.” The Guardian
For viewers seeking strong narrative propulsion or fast-moving drama, the more reflective rhythm may feel slow or “inside-baseball.”
2. Complexity and accessibility
Because the film plays with metafiction, layered narrative, and emotional subtext, some viewers may find it less immediately accessible. One review notes:
“Sentimental Value is more meditative than maybe expected…” Roger Ebert
If you prefer clearer arcs or simpler emotional setups, you might feel slightly distanced.
3. Emotional payoff vs. unresolved tension
While many praise its emotional honesty, a few mention that the film does not deliver a “tidy” resolution. The tale is less about closure and more about recognition and re-engagement. For some, that means less of a cathartic burst and more of a lingering ache. Letterboxd
🧠 My Verdict
Sentimental Value stands out as a powerful and beautifully crafted meditation on art, family, memory and the wounds that persist when we ignore them.
If I were to give a rating: 4 to 4.5 out of 5 stars.
- Superb performances, particularly Skarsgård and Reinsve.
- Visually rich, emotionally layered, and formally ambitious.
- Might not wholly satisfy those looking for plot-over-character or fast pace, but for viewers who lean into reflection and nuance, it’s one of 2025’s best.
🎯 Who Will Appreciate It & Who Might Skip
Will appreciate if you:
- Enjoy character-driven films with strong performances and emotional depth.
- Are interested in films about family, creative legacy, memory, and the cost of art.
- Like slower-burning dramas that emphasise introspection over spectacle.
Might skip if you:
- Prefer fast-paced, plot-jumping thrillers or conventional Hollywood structure.
- Seek complete story “wrap-ups” and uncomfortable ambiguity.
- Are less interested in films that more ask questions than deliver answers.
📝 Final Thoughts
Sentimental Value reminds us that sometimes the most profound stories are those we tell ourselves—about home, about our parents, about the art we make and the love we withhold. It suggests that ambition and abandonment often walk hand in hand, that the house you inherited holds echoes you didn’t know were alive, and that reconciling with what you’ve left behind might be the hardest film you ever make.
About the Author
